Monday, December 6, 2010

Accidents Happen

Reading Assignment for May30th-Jun. 3rd: Ch.11-Ch 13.

After the truck accident, Hollis tells the Old Man that she is to blame for the crash, and Steven says it's his fault? Who is right? Why?

Use evidence from the story to support your answer.

Your comment should include:

First Name and Student #

- A shared inquiry response that is free of grammatical and spelling errors.

Evidence from the book.

9 comments:

  1. Charlie 11A
    I think that they are both to blame. Steven and Hollis were both in the car at the time, it was just an accident and none of the people in the car were harmed. I would say that Steven is to blame because he was showing Hollis different ways to control the car when they lost control. Hollis is to blame because she was driving the car and not being careful.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Emily 17A

    I think it was both their falt because they made a poor choice to go up to the top of the mountan themselves. Hollis should not blame herself that much like she did in the story, because all she wanted was to see the top. Also she never would of even thought of soming happening like that, but they did go up there alone which bad things can happen. So hollis had to go back down and risk her life because of her hurt ankle.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tyrese Jensen 13A
    It was both to blame because they didn't get premission from the Old Man. Another thing is they both weren't of age.
    Stevens wasn't so post to driving at his age. He has no write to drive because he is not at age.
    Hollis is to blame too because she should not ask with out premission.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it is both of their faults because Hollis knew the old man's mountain was dangerous and slippery. It is also Steven's fault because the old man always told Steven the mountains were dangerous too. He also knew that he wasn't supposed to do it. He was just trying to help Hollis. They both didn't get permission to go anywhere.

    ReplyDelete
  5. jessica #1a
    i think it was both their faults because holllis new that the mouniten was dangeres and the old man told steven the mouniten was dangeres.

    ReplyDelete
  6. hUSSEIN #11
    I think it was both of them because their new forthe mountian. They want the old man because he is just a old man so they dont care about him.

    ReplyDelete
  7. bens 23l2

    i thought it was Josie and Hollis

    ReplyDelete
  8. Brett F.

    I think it was Hollis and Josie.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think it is hollis and Josie because it is so true that they both did it.

    ReplyDelete